• ORIGINAL RESEARCH · PUBLISHED AUGUST 23, 2026
We enquired at 200 private practices. Six offered a way to book.
The 2026 YellowHorns Private Practice Response Benchmark tested 200 practice websites across New York and New Jersey the way a prospective patient would. Every practice is named below, with what happened after we reached out.
Fieldwork August 13 to 20, 2026 · 111 in New York · 88 in New Jersey
- 200websites audited
- 136enquiries submitted
- 26replies recorded
- 4human replies
- 6offered a booking step
• KEY FINDINGS
Interest arrives. Follow-up doesn't.
No completed digital enquiry
The audit could not complete a standard enquiry because the route was unavailable, gated, manual-only or otherwise unsuitable.
No recorded response
Most successfully submitted enquiries had no classified response in the supplied observation record.
Responses were automated
Only four recorded responses were coded as human or human-like. Automation was the dominant first reply.
Offered a clear booking step
Fewer than one in four recorded responses included an identifiable invitation or route to book.
• WHERE ENQUIRIES BROKE
64 practices never let us ask.
Before response time even matters, a third of websites had no working digital route. These are the barriers we hit.
• THE DIRECTORY
All 200 practices, by name.
DOWNLOAD DIRECTORY CSV ↓Alphabetical. One observation window in August 2026, not a quality ranking. Search or filter by state and outcome.
• METHODOLOGY
How we ran it.
- 01Sample. 200 unique private-practice websites in New York and New Jersey, concentrated in functional, integrative, longevity and adjacent cash-pay categories.
- 02Enquiry. A standard, non-clinical prospective-patient enquiry through the main digital route on each website between August 13 to 20, 2026.
- 03Classification. Replies are counted only when classified as automated, human or human-like. Automated acknowledgements count as replies.
- 04Booking step. A reply counts as offering booking only when it contains an identifiable invitation or route to book.
• QUESTIONS
About this research.
YellowHorns. (2026). 2026 Private Practice Lead Response Benchmark: New York and New Jersey. https://yellowhorns.com/research/response-time-benchmark-2026
What is the 2026 Private Practice Lead Response Benchmark?
It is a YellowHorns field audit of 200 unique private-practice websites in New York and New Jersey. The study records whether a prospective patient could submit an enquiry, whether a response was recorded and classified, whether that response was automated or human, and whether it offered a clear booking step.
How many private practices responded to an online enquiry?
Of 136 successfully submitted enquiries, 26 had a classified recorded response in the supplied dataset. That is 19.1%. The other 110 submissions, or 80.9%, had no classified response in the observation record.
How many responses offered a way to book?
Six of the 26 recorded responses offered a clear booking step, equal to 23.1% of recorded responses and 4.4% of all successfully submitted enquiries.
What counts as a recorded response?
A response is counted only when the source sheet classifies it as automated, human or human-like. Automated acknowledgements are included, so the response count should not be interpreted as the number of useful or persuasive conversations.
What was the average private-practice response time?
This release does not publish an average or median response time. Several duration labels conflict with their associated timestamps, so publishing a speed statistic before reconciliation would create false precision. The report publishes the validated coverage counts instead.
Is this a representative benchmark for every U.S. private practice?
No. The sample is concentrated in New York and New Jersey and includes functional, integrative, longevity and adjacent private-practice categories. It is useful as a regional field benchmark, not a nationally representative estimate.
Can this benchmark be cited or referenced?
Yes. YellowHorns publishes the aggregate results, definitions, limitations and downloadable summary and clinic-level tables so journalists, practice operators and researchers can cite the work accurately. The directory is alphabetical and describes one observation window rather than ranking practice quality.
Which private practices were included in the benchmark?
The report contains an alphabetical clinic-by-clinic directory of all 200 websites in the audit, including practice name, specialty, city, state, website source, enquiry-route outcome, recorded response classification and booking-step result. The directory describes one observation window in August 2026 and is not a quality ranking.
• WHERE DOES YOUR PRACTICE STAND?
We'll run the same test on your practice. Free.
A web form at 7pm, an after-hours call, a DM and an AI search. You get a Revenue Leak Report and a 5-minute video.
GET MY FREE GROWTH BLUEPRINT